A snapshot of what makes Hicksville Long Island's most vibrant South Asian community — and one of its most accessible entry points for homebuyers.
Hicksville Union Free School District serves approximately 5,200 students across seven schools. Hicksville High School earns a B+ rating from Niche, with solid college placement rates and a diverse student body that reflects the community's multicultural character.
While not in the same tier as Jericho or Syosset, Hicksville's schools are improving and are well-regarded for their extracurricular programs, bilingual education resources, and the strong parental investment that comes with the community's focus on education. Many families also supplement with private tutoring and enrichment — a Hicksville tradition.
Hicksville is one of Long Island's larger unincorporated hamlets. Each area has its own price range and character — but all share the same LIRR access, diverse culture, and community amenities.
The premier residential area within Hicksville. Larger lots, newer construction, and the best-maintained streets in the hamlet. Close to Old Country Road's retail and dining corridor. Preferred by families who want Hicksville's community character and commute access at the highest price point.
The geographic and social heart of Hicksville. Walking distance to the LIRR station and close to Broadway Mall. The highest concentration of South Asian businesses, restaurants, and cultural institutions. A mix of postwar ranches and colonials, many renovated by owner-occupiers. The best option for daily commuters.
Borders Levittown to the south and offers the most affordable pricing in the hamlet. Postwar ranches and cape cods on modest lots. Some streets are exceptionally well-maintained; others have renovation upside. The lowest property taxes in Hicksville. A strong choice for first-time buyers entering the market.
The quieter eastern side of Hicksville borders Bethpage. Less dense than central Hicksville, with a more conventional suburban character. A practical choice for families who want Hicksville's price point and community but prefer fewer commercial streets and a calmer residential setting.
Answer 5 quick questions and we'll match you with the best part of Hicksville for your lifestyle.
Drag the slider to explore what homes look like at every price point.
The core of the Hicksville market. Renovated 3–4 bedroom homes with updated kitchens and baths. Central and east Hicksville offer the best selection — good proximity to the LIRR, culturally vibrant blocks, and well-maintained neighborhoods.
Hicksville Station is one of the LIRR's busiest hubs — a Major transfer point on the Main Line with frequent direct service to Penn Station and Atlantic Terminal in Brooklyn. Both eastbound and westbound trains stop here.
Main Line • LIRR
Midtown Manhattan + Downtown Brooklyn
| Location | To Midtown | Transit | Monthly Pass |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hicksville | 45 min | LIRR Main Line | $280 |
| Syosset | 50 min | LIRR Port Jeff Branch | $295 |
| Garden City | 43 min | LIRR | $280 |
| Mineola | 37 min | LIRR Main Line | $252 |
| Great Neck | 24 min express | LIRR | $252 |
You're not just choosing Hicksville — you're choosing it over somewhere else. Select where you're comparing.
| Category | This Area | Mineola |
|---|---|---|
| Commute to Midtown | 45 min LIRR | 37 min LIRR |
| Median Home Price | $620K | $700K |
| What You Get | 3–4BR colonial, yard | 3–4BR colonial, yard |
| Property Tax (Annual) | $10K typical | $13K typical |
| School District | B+ — Hicksville UFSD | #1 NY — Mineola UFSD |
| South Asian Community | One of LI's largest | Smaller presence |
| Cultural Dining | Authentic Indian, Bangladeshi, Chinese | Diverse but smaller |
| Best For | Affordability + South Asian community + culture | Top academics + fast commute + county-seat energy |
An honest look at what it costs to live in Hicksville — because smart buyers start with real data.
| Median Home Price | $620K |
| Property Taxes (Annual) | $9,000 – $14,000 |
| Effective Tax Rate | ~1.6% |
| LIRR Monthly Pass | $280 |
| vs. National Average | ~18% above |
No town is perfect. Here are the trade-offs — and why most buyers decide they're worth it.
The character, culture, and daily rhythm that make Hicksville more than a commuter suburb.
Hicksville is the undisputed center of South Asian life on Long Island. Indian, Bangladeshi, and Pakistani grocery stores, restaurants, sari shops, jewelry stores, and temples line Old Country Road and Broadway. Diwali celebrations, cultural festivals, and community events run year-round. If you're looking for a place that feels like home for South Asian families, Hicksville stands alone on Long Island.
"Hicksville has everything our family needed — our temple is five minutes away, my parents can grocery shop in their language, and the kids grow up with their culture fully intact."— A Hicksville homeowner originally from Gujarat
Old Country Road is one of the best streets for authentic South Asian food outside New York City. Dosas, biryanis, chaat, halal BBQ, Bangladeshi sweets, and Chinese-Indian fusion — the variety and quality rival anything in Jackson Heights, and parking is free.
Hicksville Station is one of the Main Line's most important hubs. Direct service to Penn Station and Atlantic Terminal makes it unusually flexible — whether you work in Midtown or Downtown Brooklyn, Hicksville has a direct train. The station's frequency during peak hours (every 20–30 min) also means less schedule-dependent commuting.
Hicksville has one of the highest concentrations of Hindu and Sikh temples on Long Island, alongside mosques, South Asian community centers, and cultural organizations. For families who want their children to grow up connected to their heritage, the infrastructure here is unmatched in suburban New York.
Just 10 minutes south, Bethpage State Park offers five golf courses (including the U.S. Open's Black Course), biking trails, sports fields, and picnic areas across 1,475 acres. One of Long Island's most accessible major parks.
Hicksville offers something increasingly rare on Long Island: a genuine pathway to homeownership for households with incomes under $120,000. Sub-$550K homes with functional layouts exist here — a vanishing category in Nassau County. For first-time buyers, Hicksville is often the most realistic option with character and community rather than a compromise.
Whether you're a first-time buyer, relocating for community, or searching for Long Island's best value — let's find the right home for your family.